.
Feedback

UPDATE: Plaza Drive Standoff Ends 'Without Further Incident or Injury'

Jonathan Gilmer, 34, of Smyrna barricaded himself with a gun inside a Smyrna home Friday.

UPDATE 11:15 p.m. An hours-long standoff at a Smyrna home has ended "without further incident or injury," said Smyrna police. Public Information Officer Michael Smith said Jonathan Gilmer, 34, of Smyrna, exited his residence after being barricaded inside since 12:30 p.m. Friday when officers deployed CS/OC gas into the home.

Gilmer was taken to Kennestone Hospital for evaluation and treatment from exposure to the gas and charges are pending. Earlier reports said the subject was barricaded inside an apartment, but in fact it was a home on Plaza Drive between South Cobb Drive and Concord Road.

Police initially responded to the home at about 12:30 p.m. Friday after a relative of the subject asked officers to do a welfare check. The family member said Gilmer was suicidal, Smyrna’s Public Information Officer Michael Smith reported.

Gilmer failed to respond to police, but later called a family member to say he was armed and would shoot anyone who came to the door, Smith said previously. Emergency Service Units, hostage negotiators and ultimately the Cobb County Sheriff’s Office Tactical Units were called to the scene.

Negotiators eventually made contact with Gilmer by phone who exited the home with a handgun, however in an email Smith noted that he didn’t threaten officers with the weapon and only threatened to use it on himself.

Gilmer re-entered the home at which time Smith said deputies deployed a tactical robot in an attempt to make further contact with him. When these efforts failed the decision was made to deploy CS/OC gas. 

UPDATE 7:30 p.m. Smyrna police continue to block access to Plaza Drive at South Cobb Drive and Old Concord Road while Tactical Units attempt to negotiate with a subject barricaded inside an apartment who is said to be armed and suicidal.

Police are not identifying the subject at this time. Smyrna-Vinings Patch will have more updates as they are available.

UPDATE 6 p.m. Police have still not identified the subject barricaded inside a Smyrna apartment on Plaza Drive. Emergency Services Units and hostage negotiators are on the scene, though Smyrna’s Public Information Officer Michael Smith emphasized that this is not a hostage situation.

“We call in Emergency Services Units, that’s our SWAT team and hostage negotiators who have the skills to deal with people who are in crisis,” he said. “We don’t have a hostage situation. It’s just one subject barricaded inside. When we say barricaded we’re not talking about he’s fortified the house in any fashion. It’s when somebody is unresponsive to us and doesn’t come out.”

A relative of the subject notified police Friday morning that they had not heard from their family member and asked officers to do a welfare check. They alerted police that the subject was suicidal and possibly armed.

Smyrna police have been on the scene since 12:30 p.m. Smith said the Sheriff’s Office Tactical Units had been called to the scene to relieve some of the Smyrna officers.

“It’s a hot day and we’re concerned about the welfare of our folks as well—staying hydrated and fatigued and that type of thing,” he said. “So we’re going to start rotating so people can get some rest, stay hydrated get some food.”

Smyrna-Vinings Patch will have more details as they’re made available.

ORGINAL STORY 5:30 p.m. Smyrna police are on the scene at an apartment complex off South Cobb Drive where an unidentified person has barricaded themself inside. The subject has told family members that he is armed and will shoot anyone who comes to the door, though police emphasize that this is not a hostage situation.

Smyrna’s Public Information Officer Michael Smith said in an email that Smyrna’s Emergency Services Unit and negotiators are on the scene. He said police were called to the apartment on Plaza Drive at 12:30 p.m. Friday after a relative of the subject requested police check the apartment. The relative told police the subject was possibly suicidal and armed.

The subject did not respond to police, but later called family members to say that he was armed and would shoot police or family who came to the door.

Smyrna-Vinings Patch will have more details as they’re available. 

Andrea Debranski July 21, 2012 at 04:37 pm
You are very lucky to have a competent police force. This is what happened in Cherokee County in May 2012 and the Sheriff thinks it was a peaceful outcome and wouldn't do anything differently. Yup, they shot and killed a suicidal teenager in his own foyer. Please read and sign our petition. https://www.change.org/petitions/justice-for-andrew-messina-policy-procedure-change-to-protect-juveniles-from-deadly-force-by-law-enforcement
Brian July 21, 2012 at 05:48 pm
I agree and I am very happy with the Smyrna police force. After dealing with some identity theft and fraud and working with both Atlanta and Smyrna police forces on different parts of it, I can say that Smyrna handled things much faster to resolve the situation for me as the victim. I found the Smyrna investigator to be well-trained and took control.
Mary K July 21, 2012 at 06:22 pm
I agree with Andrea-the Cherokee County Sheriffs Department were incompetent in handling the May 1st tragedy. The 16 year old boy was distraught, they escalated the situation with the force and presence and forced a confrontation with this boy by going to the front door after the boy told them not to come near the house or he would do something, in 70 minutes, the negotiators came near the front door, and the terrified boy broke the glass with the gun and he was executed with 1 shot from a sniper that has killed before, and was involved with a police brutality lawsuit 4 years ago in Canton. Sad--and the police sheriff will not claim any wrong doing.
Sam July 21, 2012 at 07:06 pm
Those kind of things DO happen. Ask Colorado! And would you want to be the officer to walk up to the door and say just put that gun away, after his family would not even go in. He knew the police were out there so, why didnt he just put his gun away and walk out? Sounds like the public needed protection from him.
Andrea Debranski July 21, 2012 at 07:26 pm
Protection from a sixteen year old boy hiding out in his own house only threatening to kill himself? I encourage Sam to read the petition to get the facts. There was no need for the swat team to rush the house. All they had to do was wait him out. The sheriffs office imediately started misleading the public to cover their butts. One of my favorites was that Andy put his dog out in order to intimidate the officers. The article failed to mention it was an 8 pound Shitzu. There is much more to the story. Having always been on the side of the police, this, perhaps has been the most sobering event in my life. It's good to know that there is still good law enforcement out there.
Paul Smyrna July 21, 2012 at 08:00 pm
The Smyrna Police Department and Cobb County Sheriff's office would have done the same thing that Cherokee County did, if the same circumstances existed. Had this guy pointed his gun at anyone other than himself, he would be dead. Cherokee County did exactly what they were trained to do. Had they waited him out and he snuck out the back door and shot the neighbors or someone else then who's to blame?
Paul Smyrna July 21, 2012 at 08:04 pm
They probably did know that he was alone. But when someone with a gun is making threats to kill himself and other people, you just want one officer to stand on the corner and wait for him to come out? This wasn't overkill, this was what had to be done to keep the public and the officers safe. Next time, the police should just let him run loose. When he gets to your house with the gun, call a pest control service or someone else for help since the police send to many people.
Mary K July 21, 2012 at 08:22 pm
The sniper that killed the 16 year old boy also stated he thought he heard a gun go off. Because he thought that, the boy is dead. It was broken glass from his door, yes he broke it, but the boy never shot a gun in his life, and he was 5'3" tall. He was a child, and he would have never been able to get a shot off, and law enforcement knew that about him. I have respect for the police, but the make mistakes too. When they make mistakes, they must be accountable like everyone else. They must look at it and learn from it and be willing to make changes to help prevent such a tragic event from happening again.
Freya Stark July 21, 2012 at 09:45 pm
Why did it take a SWAT team armed to the teeth hours to get one man with one gun to come out of one house? One canister of tear gas got him out in a hurry. It could have gotten him out just as fast eight hours earlier.
Also a SWAT team is a special group of police officers trained to deal with unusually dangerous or violent situations, and having special weapons more powerful than those carried by regular police. Note the words unusually dangerous and violent situations.
Inside-Out July 21, 2012 at 11:35 pm
1) It wasn't the SWAT team, it was an Emergency Service unit
2) This is a highly trained unit, TRAINED to deal with these types of situations. 3) The members of this unit are trained and have specialized less than lethal weapons 4) You should get your facts gathered prior to writing a post about something that you know nothing about 5) These officers have to know all of the details before moving up in the use of force. There was no way in knowing if he had any hostages or innocent people in that house. 6) It in fact took several rounds of gas to get him out of the house, not to mention that there is a serious risk of fire being ignited by using the gas in a house, putting the entire neighborhood at risk as well as compromising the safety of the officers. 7) If they reacted to quickly without knowing the facts there would be those tha complain that there was no rush involved in taking action. 8) You should send the Smyrna Police your phone number so they can call you to handle these types of situations in the future, as you know how to handle them so well. 9) A man with a gun threatening to kill anyone who approaches his home is not considered an unusally dangerous situation ? Wow. 10) God Bless the Smyrna Police Department and the members of the Emergency Services Unit. I am so sorry that this community has some people in it that just don't get it.Those that will not hesitate to call you in an emergency and that you will run in to protect while others run away.
Mary K July 22, 2012 at 12:36 am
Sam-no one was in danger but the boy. All people where either in the house or down the street. No one was in danger.
Another Angry Mom July 22, 2012 at 02:05 am
Inside Out, Bravo and well said. Kudos to Smyrna Police for handling this situation professionally, un-rushed, and putting their training to great use. The Andrew Messina case is troubling on many levels. This 34 year old was much more of a threat than 16 year old Andrew, and the outcome much better. Why? Because of the training, and professionalism. Smyrna you guys did a fantastic job. Please do to go the petition site and read this story: http://www.change.org/petitions/justice-for-andrew-messina-policy-procedure-change-to-protect-juveniles-from-deadly-force-by-law-enforcement
Another Angry Mom July 22, 2012 at 02:10 am
Freya, I have a GREAT example of what happens when a SWAT or Emergency Service Unit RUSHES a conclusion. It is NEVER a good outcome. If someone is threatening suicide they are obviously emotionally fragile. It takes time, and training for these men and women to do their job. This is the example of what I am referring to, please read this: http://www.change.org/petitions/justice-for-andrew-messina-policy-procedure-change-to-protect-juveniles-from-deadly-force-by-law-enforcement
Andrea Debranski July 22, 2012 at 03:22 am
How do we get one of those emergency services units in Cherokee County? Very impressive. Sadly, we don't have that kind of expertise in Cherokee County.
JustTheFaxMaam July 22, 2012 at 05:06 am
Did you see and hear the videos that Andrew had made and were released by the GBI? And did you hear the 911 call from his mother saying he was pointing the gun at her and did you hear her state she was afriad he would go outside with it? Please be sure that these people hear both sides of the story and let them make their own decisions in this as they like. You are leaving out pertinent information much like what was left out of the petition where it was stated that the gun he had was not loaded when the video clearly showed it as being loaded. The video he was making himslef I might add. This was a sad situation for sure but you are just trying to get something started by coming on here and posting these comments IMO
Mary K July 22, 2012 at 10:52 am
Just TheFaxMaam--The facts remain the same. The gun was not loaded when the mom was in the house. Yes he did load the gun sometime after. He NEVER went outside. He only let is 10 lb puppy out so it would not get hurt. Garrison the police sheriff found it necessary to lie a couple times about that! He wanted people to think he wanted the puppy to attack the police! How stupid and laughable!!!
See link below, not only did this man have a gun, he shot at police. After 11 hours he walked out alive. They gave him time-he was NOT executed. Also they used the armored car called the Bear Cat--why was'nt used for the Messina boy-WHY? This event was so mishandled--Thank God other counties have the proper training and common sense. I would like to know who was in charge on May 1st and what experience they had! A question that should be addressed. http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/18/12274275-new-jersey-cop-surrenders-after-10-hour-standoff-with-police?lite
Mary K July 22, 2012 at 10:59 am
Andrea--David Waters has said, he will get rid of people some of them that were involved in that tragic event and put his own, trained people in. The sniper will go!!! He has killed before, and has also been involved in a police brutality case 4 years ago in the city of Canton. He has had his time. There are alot of cowboys running around in Cherokee County and they are led by Garrison. I am sorry if I have offended anyone, but that is how I feel.
Freya Stark July 22, 2012 at 01:49 pm
I get the impression from the above posts most of you aren't old enough to remember the Kent State Shooting (also referred to as the Kent State Massacre) May 4, 1970. Guardsmen fired 67 rounds over a period of 13 seconds killing four students and wounding nine others, A picture of the young woman crying beside her dead friend is iconic. There's also The Stonewall riots a series of spontaneous, violent demonstrations against a police raid that took place June 28, 1969 in Manhattan, During the 1968 Democratic National Convention in Chicago protestors and police battled for eight days. Fast forward to Occupy Wall Street November 2011 UC Davis. A police officer casually pepper sprayed passive protestors.
Are all police/law enforcement bad? No. But you've got to know your history. Police brutality if a part of our history and is still occurring. Never have total confidence in law enforcement in the U.S. Question authority. All authority. From the local to the national level. http://www.october22.org/
226 July 22, 2012 at 03:43 pm
You've invalidated your own argument. The first scenario did not involve police, but National Guardsmen. Second, every other situation you've described was a police response to civil unrest where there was as you said there was "violent demonstrations". I do agree that there are still incidents of police brutality occurring.
Also, have you seen the entire UNEDITED video of the UC Davis incident? If you so you would've seen the officer plead with the students to obey the lawful orders of police and make them aware of the consequences if they refused. You would've also seen prior to the the mob surround the police and clearly threaten them with profanities that they would not let the police leave until the students were release. Question the media before you question authority.
Neal Dow July 22, 2012 at 05:16 pm
If what you say is true you might consider filing a lawsuit.
Neal Dow July 22, 2012 at 05:25 pm
Andrew - law enforcement is anyone who enforces the law. The Stonewall riots happened because the gay community and others were fed up with the violence the police used against them. Civil unrest is defined as a symptom of and a form of protest against major socio-political problems.
Neal Dow July 22, 2012 at 05:27 pm
When governments fear the people there is liberty. When people fear their government there is tryanny.
226 July 22, 2012 at 06:08 pm
Well which one was it, civil unrest or riot? Go ahead and cut/paste the wikipedia definition of riot now.
Wahrheit-Teller July 22, 2012 at 08:11 pm
Sam and everyone else here need to understand this is an election year and Mary K and her ilk are political hacks. They represent a committee exploiting this incident to get their candidate elected and they willfully ignore all the facts which have come out since the incident to further their agenda. First it was he was no threat to anyone and then we see video of him saying he was going to blow someone's brains out. Then the HNT was not trained in how to deal with mentally disturbed individuals and they needed a trained mental health professional on scene when the lead at the scene has a masters in Psychology and worked in the mental health profession for years, not to mention teaches CIT to law enforcement around the state ( plus all HNT members are CIT certified).
Their group has zero creditably when their face book banner is a Vote David Waters sign. And if you dare question them or point out anything contrary to their group think and echo chamber mantra, you will be accused of being Roger Garrison ( the incumbent sheriff). Because in their world view, only the incumbent ( who has time apparently to spend on message boards) would challenge their righteous cause. Just fair warning to all on here. They are hacks who can't back up anything they are saying with facts when called out.
Wahrheit-Teller July 22, 2012 at 08:13 pm
JustTheFaxmaam, remember, it's the Justice for Andrew Messina Committee to Elect David Waters. Where facts just get in the way.
Wahrheit-Teller July 22, 2012 at 08:14 pm
Again, in the 911 calls, she clearly states he is loading the gun. So she was right there when he was loading the gun. Stop lying.
Wahrheit-Teller July 22, 2012 at 08:17 pm
http://woodstock.patch.com/articles/911-call-from-messina-s-mother#video-9794478
Either you are lying or you truly have no clue about what you are talking about.
Mary K July 23, 2012 at 12:27 am
Sabrina--I feel for you, but be thankful your husband is alive. Lies in the media are awful, I hope you can get your side out. The police sometimes have a way of telling and twisting the media. God bless you and your family!
Neal Dow July 23, 2012 at 01:03 am
If you believe your civil rights were violated contact a lawyer, take pictures of the damage, document everything, and get the names of all of the officers and news reporters that were at your house. Get someone to help you get that information.
226 July 23, 2012 at 12:50 pm
What motivation do the police have to lie about what happened?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Smyrna-Vinings Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Atlanta Glamdoll June 15, 2013 at 07:04 pm
Are these the apartments that were once called "Garrison Plantation"?
Lissa K. June 15, 2013 at 09:32 pm
This is Garrison Plantation - Garrison Lakes - Lakefront Vista. I lived there when it was familyRead More owned. It went from sister to brother then sold. Changed name from Garrison Plantation (because it wasn't PC) (but no one thought about what a garrison was) to Garrison Lakes (there's only one lake) to Lakefront Vista (under new ownership.) It's a dump now. The layout and size of the apts. are great. Even the location is great. Still know some people there. But it went downhill.
MA Evans June 3, 2013 at 09:20 pm
I'd rather answer the question "How do you feel about Roswell Street Baptist Church?" MyRead More answer: can't stand it. This incident is just another in its long and bigoted history. During the anti gay lifestyle debacle it gave out copies of the 10 Commandments. That anti gay resolution drafted by Gordon Wysong and enacted by the Cobb Co. Commissioners cost the county an Olympic venue. Whenever I hear about that church I think of the OM who called the church's prominent members The Marietta Mafia!
Jim Lyon June 4, 2013 at 01:20 am
Its sad, that young people who are gay and often struggle to accept themselves as they are, faceRead More such fury and rejection by a church that preaches love, compassion and forgiveness for most but not all. No wonder many young people, the vast majority of whom are or will be heterosexual find the church increasingly irrelevant in their lives with attitudes like this.